Downton Abbey: Poor Anna

anna downton abbey(Series 4, ep.3)  ITV didn’t send out any preview DVDs to the press for this episode, prompting speculation that Something Big was going to happen. On the previous occasions when they apparently didn’t send out previews, we lost Lady Sybil and Matthew Crawley in shock episodes.

My money was on Mrs Patmore shuffling off the mortal coil  mid-dinner service. It’s true that she did take a bit of a funny turn, but it turned out to be a red herring of a panic attack and she will live to bake pie another day.

In a house full of new people, frankly anything could have happened. Even Dame Kiri Te Kanawa turned up, as Dame Nellie Melba. Having an opera singer in the house was almost too much for His Lordship, who didn’t think it was quite seemly to have the world famous chanteuse eating at his dinner table and ordered a tray to be sent up. Her Ladyship is made of more modern stock (she’s American), so she overturned his tray plan and insisted that Dame Nellie would sit next to him at dinner and they darn well would make small talk, so there.

Also at the dinner party was Lord Gillingham, a potential new love interest for Mary. Edith brought her married boyfriend, who proceeded to ingratiate himself with Lord G by winning all his money back from a card shark. And there was a nasty visiting servant Green, played by Nigel Harman.

And he was the source of the expected shock. He didn’t die – there weren’t any deaths apart from a further nail in the coffin of Molesley’s self respect when he went from road mender to delivery boy to footman in the space of one episode. What Green did was actually worse – he raped The Sainted Anna.

The actual rape wasn’t shown, though we saw him hit her and drag her into a room. What was most distressing was her reaction afterwards, as she begged Mrs Hughes not to tell anybody, in case Bates tried to take revenge and ended up in prison with a death sentence over him. Joanne Froggatt was excellent, showing Anna trying to put on her usual calm facade as if nothing had happened, but  letting us see how traumatised she was.

It really was a shocking incident and I find myself completely unable to decide whether I thought it was gratuitous and a bit exploitative. I think I’ll have to wait and see how the aftermath unfolds in coming episodes. What I do know is that this is one episode that didn’t leave me with a happy, satisfied smile on my face.

3 Comments

Filed under Downton Abbey

3 responses to “Downton Abbey: Poor Anna

  1. I was reading the Guardian blog on this episode and it said the problem with Downton (or Downtown as I called it on Twitter this week) is that everyone is sketched shallowly. Not the fault of the actors, but the way Fellowes writes means that everyone’s characters are skimmed over lightly in the writing, which means we don’t really get close to anyone or care that much (this is also true of the Archers, for me anyway). This mean, for me, it DID feel exploitative, the rape I mean. The card sharp/shark (never sure which) come uppance part was amusing tho’, that suited the shallowness. But a violent rape? Nope.

    • Sue

      I don’t necessarily agree with the Guardian person. I think we know Anna well enough by now to care about her, and I definitely care about Lady Mary. The closest I can articulate how I felt about last night’s episode was that when Sybil died there was a context to it (she was pregnant, and there was the reaction of all the family around her too) and when Matthew died we were expecting something to happen to him (Dan Stevens was leaving), but this was quite out of the blue and felt like, “Now, who can we have something awful happen to?” and it’s just depressing that probably the strongest, most sympathetic female character has to suffer a rape – and it felt quite random. I feel like I want to wait and see how the aftermath plays out in the forthcoming episodes to give it a context. If that makes sense.

  2. HolbyNut

    Yes, it was so shocking and I actually gasped out loud.
    Mrs Hughes will help to get justice in the end as she saw the awful Green coming back to take his seat during the singing. Though undoubtedly, this will take many episodes of torture for Anna and Mr Bates.
    On a separate note, I’m finding the empathy between Tom and Matthew’s Mum very touching.
    Looking forward to next week….I think!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s